Best Areas to Stay on Cat Island: Where to Base Your Bahamas Trip
Cat Island is long, lightly developed, and distinctly different from the resort-centered islands of The Bahamas. Choosing where to stay matters because accommodations, restaurants, beaches, airports, and attractions are spread among small settlements rather than concentrated in one tourism district.
For many travelers, New Bight and the central part of Cat Island offer the most practical base for sightseeing. Visitors prioritizing quiet beaches may prefer Pigeon Cay, Bennett's Harbour, Orange Creek, or Port Howe, while travelers interested in fishing and marina access can consider the southern end of the island.
Cat Island has two airports: Arthur's Town Airport serves the northern end, while New Bight Airport serves the central part of the island. New Bight is also close to Mount Alvernia and The Hermitage, making the central area particularly useful for first-time visitors.
Before choosing a base, travelers planning a longer trip should also explore the Ultimate Cat Island Travel Guide for information on beaches, attractions, transportation, dining, and activities across the island.
NEW BIGHT & FERNANDEZ BAY — BEST FOR FIRST-TIME VISITORS
For travelers wondering where to stay on Cat Island for a first visit, the New Bight area is one of the most practical choices.
New Bight sits near the center of the island and provides convenient access to one of Cat Island's most important landmarks: Mount Alvernia and The Hermitage. At 206 feet, Mount Alvernia is the highest point in The Bahamas. The area also has the New Bight Fish Fry and access to New Bight Airport.
Nearby Fernandez Bay adds a quieter beachfront setting without placing visitors far from the central part of Cat Island.
One established accommodation in this area is Fernandez Bay Village, located at Fernandez Bay near New Bight.
Best for: first-time visitors, couples, sightseeing trips, beach stays and travelers who want a relatively central base.
Why stay here:
- Central position for exploring different parts of Cat Island
- Convenient access to New Bight Airport
- Near Mount Alvernia and The Hermitage
- Access to New Bight's Fish Fry and local services
- Combination of beach access and sightseeing convenience
For travelers planning to explore Cat Island beyond their accommodation, this is one of the strongest all-around bases.
OLD BIGHT & THE CENTRAL-SOUTH AREA — BEST FOR BEACHFRONT RELAXATION
Old Bight and the surrounding central-southern coast suit travelers who want their accommodation to be part of the experience rather than simply somewhere to sleep between sightseeing stops.
The area combines long stretches of shoreline with access to settlements along Cat Island's main north-south road.
Rollezz Villas Beach Resort is located at Joe Sound Creek in Old Bight Settlement, illustrating the type of beachfront resort experience available in this part of Cat Island.
This area works particularly well for visitors who expect to spend substantial time swimming, walking the beach, relaxing at their accommodation, or making selective day trips rather than driving across the island every day.
Best for: couples, families, relaxed beach vacations and travelers seeking a quieter resort base.
BENNETT'S HARBOUR & PIGEON CAY — BEST FOR QUIET BEACHES
Travelers searching for a quieter side of Cat Island should consider Bennett's Harbour and Pigeon Cay.
This part of the island is particularly appealing when the priority is beach time, privacy and a slower daily schedule. It is less about being close to every major attraction and more about having easy access to uncrowded coastal surroundings.
Accommodation options include Pigeon Cay Beach Club at Pigeon Cay Beach and Curly's Beach Resort in Bennett's Harbour Settlement.
Pigeon Cay is especially suited to travelers who imagine their Cat Island vacation revolving around swimming, reading, beach walks and relaxed days rather than a packed sightseeing itinerary.
Best for: couples, repeat Bahamas visitors, slow travel and travelers prioritizing quiet beachfront surroundings.
A rental car remains useful for exploring attractions, restaurants and settlements elsewhere on Cat Island.
ORANGE CREEK & THE NORTH — BEST FOR A REMOTE NORTH CAT ISLAND STAY
Orange Creek provides a useful northern base for travelers interested in exploring the less-developed northern portion of Cat Island.
Orange Creek Inn provides self-catering accommodation in Orange Creek, while Shannas Cove Resort is located around Shanna Bay near Orange Creek.
The northern end is also served by Arthur's Town Airport. The official Bahamas tourism site identifies Arthur's Town as Cat Island's capital and confirms that the nearby airport serves northern Cat Island.
Staying here makes particular sense when the accommodation itself, northern beaches and a quieter environment are more important than being centrally positioned for island-wide sightseeing.
Best for: privacy, couples, independent travelers and visitors specifically exploring northern Cat Island.
ARTHUR'S TOWN — BEST FOR NORTHERN CAT ISLAND ACCESS
Arthur's Town is another logical base for travelers whose itinerary focuses on northern Cat Island.
The settlement is historically significant as the birthplace of actor and diplomat Sidney Poitier and is served by nearby Arthur's Town Airport.
Compared with New Bight, staying around Arthur's Town places travelers farther from Mount Alvernia and many central and southern locations. The tradeoff is easier access to northern communities and beaches.
Arthur's Town is therefore better viewed as a strategic northern base rather than the default choice for every first-time visitor.
Best for: northern-island exploration, local settlement experiences and travelers arriving through Arthur's Town Airport.
PORT HOWE — BEST FOR A SECLUDED EAST-COAST EXPERIENCE
Port Howe offers a different Cat Island experience: fewer distractions, extensive coastal scenery and accommodation designed around staying close to the beach.
Greenwood Beach Resort is located in Port Howe and represents one of the established accommodation options in this section of the island.
Port Howe is particularly attractive to travelers whose priorities include swimming, diving, beach walks and spending substantial time at their resort.
The location is less convenient for visitors planning frequent trips to northern Cat Island, so travelers should consider driving distances before choosing it as a base.
Best for: beach-focused vacations, couples, divers and travelers seeking seclusion.
SOUTHERN CAT ISLAND — BEST FOR FISHING & MARINA-FOCUSED TRIPS
The southern end of Cat Island is worth considering for travelers whose itinerary revolves around boating, fishing or spending most of their time around a resort.
Hawks Nest Resort & Marina in McQueen's Settlement provides a resort-and-marina base in southern Cat Island.
Cat Island supports both offshore sport fishing and bonefishing in creeks and flats, making fishing an important part of the island's visitor experience.
For travelers primarily interested in exploring Mount Alvernia, Arthur's Town and the north, however, basing themselves this far south creates longer drives.
Best for: anglers, boaters, marina users and travelers who plan to spend most of their vacation around their resort.
WHICH AREA OF CAT ISLAND SHOULD YOU CHOOSE?
There is no single best area to stay on Cat Island for every traveler. The right location depends primarily on how much of the island you intend to explore.
Choose New Bight or Fernandez Bay if this is your first visit and you want a practical central location.
Choose Old Bight if beachfront relaxation is more important than being beside major attractions.
Choose Bennett's Harbour or Pigeon Cay if quiet beaches and a slower pace are your priorities.
Choose Orange Creek or Arthur's Town if you want to concentrate on northern Cat Island.
Choose Port Howe for a secluded coastal stay with beach and diving appeal.
Choose southern Cat Island if fishing, boating or marina access defines your itinerary.
Because Cat Island's visitor infrastructure is distributed among settlements rather than concentrated in one town, choosing a location based purely on the appearance of a hotel can lead to unnecessary driving.
DO YOU NEED A RENTAL CAR ON CAT ISLAND?
For most independent travelers who want to explore beyond their resort, renting a vehicle is one of the most practical ways to experience Cat Island.
This becomes especially important if your plans include visiting Mount Alvernia, exploring several settlements, trying restaurants away from your accommodation or visiting beaches in different sections of the island.
Travelers planning a resort-centered vacation may need a vehicle less frequently, particularly if airport transfers, meals and activities can be arranged through their accommodation.
Before booking, ask your property about airport transfers and vehicle rentals so transportation is arranged before arrival.
WHICH CAT ISLAND AIRPORT SHOULD YOU FLY INTO?
Cat Island has two airports serving different parts of the island.
New Bight Airport (TBI) is the more convenient arrival point for New Bight, Fernandez Bay and much of central Cat Island. The airport is near Mount Alvernia and has Customs and Immigration facilities for international travelers.
Arthur's Town Airport (ATC) serves northern Cat Island and can be more convenient for accommodations around Arthur's Town, Orange Creek and the northern part of the island.
Travelers should therefore consider their accommodation location before choosing flights rather than automatically selecting an airport and arranging lodging afterward.
BEST AREA FOR COUPLES
Couples have several strong choices depending on the type of trip they want.
Fernandez Bay combines beachfront surroundings with a convenient central location, while Pigeon Cay, Orange Creek and Port Howe provide greater separation from the island's main visitor routes.
For couples planning a quiet trip built around swimming, dining and long beach days, choosing a beachfront property may be more valuable than choosing the most geographically central settlement.
BEST AREA FOR FAMILIES
Families should consider convenience, beach conditions, food availability, room configuration and transportation alongside scenery.
Central Cat Island can simplify sightseeing because major areas are reachable without starting every excursion from the extreme north or south.
Families planning mostly beach and resort time may instead prefer a beachfront property where swimming, meals and activities require minimal daily travel.
The best choice depends heavily on children's ages and whether the family intends to explore the island extensively.
BEST AREA FOR BEACH LOVERS
Cat Island's low-density development means travelers can find beachfront accommodation in several parts of the island rather than being restricted to one resort strip.
Pigeon Cay, Fernandez Bay, Old Bight and Port Howe are among the areas worth comparing for a beach-centered vacation.
Rather than simply searching for the "best beach," consider whether you prefer calm swimming, long beach walks, snorkeling or diving access, and how often you expect to leave your accommodation.
BEST AREA FOR FIRST-TIME VISITORS
For most first-time visitors who want a combination of beaches and sightseeing, the New Bight–Fernandez Bay area is a strong starting point.
Its central location makes it easier to reach different parts of Cat Island, while proximity to New Bight Airport and Mount Alvernia simplifies two important parts of a typical first trip: arrival and sightseeing.
Travelers who already know they want a primarily beach-based, fishing-focused or secluded vacation may benefit more from one of the island's northern or southern bases.
BEST TIME TO STAY ON CAT ISLAND
Where you stay matters throughout the year, but weather and seasonal conditions can influence how travelers use the island.
For a beach-focused trip, check expected weather and sea conditions shortly before travel. Visitors interested in fishing, diving or boating should also confirm seasonal conditions and activity availability with local operators.
Accommodation and transportation availability can be more limited than on Nassau or other major tourism centers, so advance planning is especially valuable when travel dates are fixed.
FAQS ABOUT WHERE TO STAY ON CAT ISLAND
WHAT IS THE BEST AREA TO STAY ON CAT ISLAND FOR FIRST-TIME VISITORS?
New Bight and nearby Fernandez Bay are strong choices because of their central location, proximity to New Bight Airport and convenient access to Mount Alvernia and The Hermitage.
WHERE SHOULD COUPLES STAY ON CAT ISLAND?
Couples seeking quiet beachfront surroundings can consider Fernandez Bay, Pigeon Cay, Orange Creek, Bennett's Harbour or Port Howe, depending on how much island exploration they plan.
IS NEW BIGHT A GOOD PLACE TO STAY ON CAT ISLAND?
Yes. New Bight is particularly practical for sightseeing-oriented visitors because it is centrally located near New Bight Airport, Mount Alvernia and The Hermitage.
CAN YOU STAY NEAR QUIET BEACHES ON CAT ISLAND?
Yes. Cat Island has small-scale beachfront accommodations in several areas, including Pigeon Cay, Fernandez Bay, Old Bight, Orange Creek and Port Howe.
ARE THERE RESORTS THROUGHOUT CAT ISLAND?
Accommodations are distributed across several parts of the island rather than concentrated in one large resort district. Options range from small inns and self-catering properties to beachfront resorts.
HOW DO YOU CHOOSE BETWEEN NORTH AND SOUTH CAT ISLAND?
Choose northern Cat Island for access to Arthur's Town, Orange Creek and northern beaches. Central and southern locations may be better for Mount Alvernia, New Bight, Port Howe, fishing or marina-oriented trips.
IS IT BETTER TO STAY NEAR NEW BIGHT AIRPORT?
It can be, particularly for first-time visitors. However, travelers staying in northern Cat Island may find Arthur's Town Airport geographically more convenient.
WHY DOES LOCATION MATTER ON CAT ISLAND?
Cat Island is geographically spread out, with settlements, accommodations, beaches and attractions distributed along the island. Choosing the right base can significantly reduce unnecessary driving.
EXPLORE MORE CAT ISLAND GUIDES
Use this accommodation guide as the starting point for choosing a base, then continue planning with:
LOCAL & DESTINATION CONTEXT
Cat Island is part of The Bahamas' Out Islands, where small settlements, beaches and locally operated accommodations shape the visitor experience. New Bight and Mount Alvernia anchor much of the island's central sightseeing, while Arthur's Town and Orange Creek provide access to the north and Port Howe and southern communities extend the experience farther down the island. Beaches, fishing grounds, reefs, creeks and coastal settlements are interconnected, so accommodation location influences how easily travelers can combine swimming, sightseeing, fishing, diving and local dining during a Cat Island vacation.
CONCLUSION
The best area to stay on Cat Island depends less on finding a single tourism center and more on matching your accommodation location to your itinerary.
New Bight and Fernandez Bay are particularly practical for first-time visitors and sightseeing. Pigeon Cay, Bennett's Harbour and Orange Creek suit travelers seeking quieter northern surroundings, while Port Howe and southern Cat Island work well for travelers prioritizing beaches, diving, fishing or marina access.
Before booking, compare the location of your accommodation with your arrival airport and the places you most want to visit. That simple planning step can reduce driving and make a Cat Island itinerary considerably more efficient.
For the broader destination picture, continue to the Ultimate Cat Island Travel Guide to explore Cat Island's beaches, historic sites, settlements, dining, fishing and other experiences.
Cat Island, The Bahamas, Out Islands, New Bight, Fernandez Bay, Old Bight, Bennett's Harbour, Pigeon Cay, Orange Creek, Arthur's Town, Port Howe, McQueen's Settlement, Mount Alvernia, The Hermitage, New Bight Airport, Arthur's Town Airport, Fernandez Bay, Joe Sound Creek, Shanna Bay, Cat Island beaches, Atlantic Ocean, coastal ecosystems, coral reefs, creeks, flats, bonefishing, sport fishing, diving, snorkeling, swimming, beach vacations, couples travel, family travel, Bahamas accommodations, Cat Island hotels, Cat Island resorts, where to stay on Cat Island, best areas to stay on Cat Island, rental cars, airport transfers, island transportation
Updated as of August 2026.