Cat Cay Guide: History, Marina & Visiting This Exclusive Private Island
INTRODUCTION
Located approximately 10 miles (16 km) south of North Bimini, Cat Cay is one of the most exclusive private islands in The Bahamas. Consisting of North Cat Cay and South Cat Cay, the islands are renowned for the prestigious Cat Cay Yacht Club, world-class sport fishing, protected marina, and fascinating history dating back to the era of Caribbean piracy.
Unlike most Bahamian destinations, Cat Cay is not a public resort island. Access is generally limited to yacht club members, property owners, invited guests, and authorized visitors. Nevertheless, its proximity to Bimini makes it a well-known landmark for boaters, anglers, and travelers interested in the region's maritime heritage. The island also serves as an official Bahamian port of entry for many private yachts arriving from Florida.
This guide focuses specifically on Cat Cay's history, marina, visitor access, and nearby experiences. For a complete overview of Bimini's beaches, restaurants, accommodations, and attractions, continue with the Ultimate Bimini Travel Guide.
WHERE IS CAT CAY?
Cat Cay lies at the southern end of the Bimini island chain, between the Florida Straits and the Great Bahama Bank.
Nearby destinations include:
Its strategic location has made it an important waypoint for recreational boating and offshore fishing for decades.
THE HISTORY OF CAT CAY
Cat Cay has a colorful past that stretches from pirate legends to luxury yachting.
Historically, the island was associated with:
-
Blackbeard (Edward Teach)
-
Pirate Charles Vane
-
Early maritime trade
-
Private ownership during the 20th century
-
The founding of the Cat Cay Yacht Club
By the mid-1900s, Cat Cay had become one of the Caribbean's premier destinations for sport fishermen, attracting celebrities, business leaders, and politicians. Today, it remains a private club community while preserving its long-standing maritime traditions.
CAT CAY YACHT CLUB
Established in 1945, the Cat Cay Yacht Club is one of the oldest and most respected private yacht clubs in The Bahamas.
The club features:
Membership is private, and most facilities are reserved for members and their sponsored guests.
THE MARINA
The marina is among Cat Cay's defining features.
Highlights include:
-
Protected harbor
-
More than 100 yacht slips
-
Berths for vessels up to approximately 160 feet
-
Fuel dock
-
Shore power
-
Fresh water
-
Wi-Fi
-
Customs clearance facilities
Because Cat Cay is an official port of entry, many boaters clear Bahamian customs here before continuing to Bimini or other islands.
WORLD-CLASS SPORT FISHING
Cat Cay has long been recognized as one of the premier offshore fishing destinations in The Bahamas.
Common target species include:
-
Blue marlin
-
White marlin
-
Sailfish
-
Wahoo
-
Mahi-mahi
-
Yellowfin tuna
-
Blackfin tuna
-
Grouper
-
Snapper
Its location near the edge of the Gulf Stream provides quick access to deep-water fishing grounds that have attracted anglers for generations.
CAN YOU VISIT CAT CAY?
This is one of the most common questions travelers ask.
In general:
-
North Cat Cay is privately owned.
-
Landing on the island requires authorization.
-
Yacht club members and invited guests have access.
-
Most public visitors cannot freely explore the island.
However, visiting boaters may be able to enter the marina for customs clearance or approved marina services, subject to current policies and availability.
THINGS TO SEE NEAR CAT CAY
Although Cat Cay itself is private, nearby Bimini offers numerous public attractions.
Popular nearby experiences include:
-
Radio Beach
-
Blister Beach
-
Bimini Road
-
SS Sapona Shipwreck
-
Snorkeling tours
-
Shark diving
-
Dolphin excursions
-
Fishing charters
-
Alice Town
-
Honeymoon Harbour
Many visitors combine these experiences while viewing Cat Cay from the water during boating excursions.
TRAVELER PLANNING INFORMATION
Transportation
Cat Cay can be reached by:
Most travelers first arrive in North Bimini before accessing nearby waters.
Accessibility
Best Time to Visit
The peak boating and fishing season generally runs from late fall through spring, when weather and sea conditions are often most favorable.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Is Cat Cay open to the public?
No. Cat Cay is a private island, and access is generally limited to members, property owners, invited guests, and authorized visitors.
Where is Cat Cay located?
Cat Cay lies approximately 10 miles south of North Bimini in the Bimini island chain.
Can yachts clear customs at Cat Cay?
Yes. Cat Cay serves as an official Bahamian port of entry for eligible private vessels arriving from abroad.
Why is Cat Cay famous?
The island is known for its exclusive yacht club, protected marina, legendary sport fishing, and historical association with pirates and early offshore angling.
Is there an airport on Cat Cay?
Yes. North Cat Cay has a private airstrip primarily serving members and authorized flights.
Can tourists stay overnight on Cat Cay?
Overnight accommodations are generally reserved for members, homeowners, and invited guests of the Cat Cay Yacht Club.
What is the closest public destination to Cat Cay?
North Bimini and Alice Town are the nearest public destinations, offering beaches, restaurants, snorkeling, diving, and boating activities.
EXPLORE MORE BIMINI GUIDES
LOCAL & DESTINATION CONTEXT
Cat Cay forms part of the Bimini island chain, alongside North Bimini, South Bimini, Gun Cay, and nearby marine attractions such as the SS Sapona Shipwreck and Bimini Road. While Cat Cay itself remains a private destination centered around its historic yacht club and marina, the surrounding waters connect visitors to some of The Bahamas' finest fishing grounds, snorkeling sites, and boating routes. Together, these neighboring destinations highlight the maritime heritage that has made the Bimini region one of the country's premier boating and sport fishing hubs.
CONCLUSION
Cat Cay offers a fascinating glimpse into one of The Bahamas' most exclusive private island communities. Although public access is limited, its renowned marina, legendary sport fishing, and rich maritime history continue to make it a landmark within the Bimini chain. Whether you're arriving by yacht, planning an offshore fishing adventure, or simply exploring nearby waters, Cat Cay remains an iconic part of the region's nautical heritage.
For public beaches, accommodations, restaurants, diving, and complete vacation planning, continue with the Ultimate Bimini Travel Guide.
Cat Cay, North Cat Cay, South Cat Cay, Cat Cay Yacht Club, Cat Cay Marina, Cat Cay Airport, Bimini, North Bimini, South Bimini, Alice Town, Gun Cay, Honeymoon Harbour, Great Bahama Bank, Florida Straits, Gulf Stream, SS Sapona Shipwreck, Bimini Road, sport fishing, blue marlin, white marlin, sailfish, wahoo, mahi-mahi, tuna, customs, marina, yacht club, private island, boating, snorkeling, diving, Bahamas port of entry